23 NYCRR Part 500, as amended with effect from 1 November 2023

NYDFS Cybersecurity Regulation: penetration testing and the evidence it leaves

Part 500 is the one regulation on this list that names penetration testing, and then asks for more: automated scans with a manual review of what they miss, a monitoring process, and remediation ranked by risk, all under a written policy. One program can answer the whole of it and leave the record the 15 April certification rests on.

The dates

When it applies.

  1. 01Original regulation in effectmilestone
  2. 02Amended regulation in effectin-force
  3. 03Annual certification dueThe date that matters

JurisdictionNew York State. Entities licensed, registered or chartered under New York Banking, Insurance or Financial Services Law, wherever they operate.

  1. Covered entities, meaning anyone operating under a license, registration, charter, certificate, permit, accreditation or similar authorization under the Banking Law, the Insurance Law or the Financial Services Law.
  2. Section 500.5 applies to every covered entity, with the limited exemptions in Section 500.19. The largest firms, Class A companies, carry further duties elsewhere in Part 500.
  3. Third-party service providers are reached through Section 500.11, which requires covered entities to assess them.
One program

Six obligations. One program, one record.

Section 500.3 and Section 500.5 describe one thing, a policy, the program that runs under it and the evidence that it ran. Firms that buy each piece from a different party end up with seams, and examiners notice the seams. We run the whole chain.

  1. 01§500.3

    Written policy

    Drafted with you around the program, so what the policy promises is what actually runs.

    Program review
  2. 02§500.5(a)(1)

    Annual test

    Inside and outside the boundaries, by a CREST-accredited team, every finding proven by exploitation.

    Penetration testing
  3. 03§500.5(a)(2)

    Automated testing + manual review

    Incenter tests the information systems continuously and after any material change. A senior reviews what the automation cannot reach.

    Incenter
  4. 04§500.5(b)

    Monitoring

    The same continuous testing, so each new vulnerability arrives with proof instead of an identifier.

    IncenterExaminers ask here
  5. 05§500.5(c)

    Remediation + re-test

    Ranked by what would breach you, closed in a sprint, then re-tested so "remediated" is true.

    Closure sprintExaminers ask here
  6. 06§500.17

    Certification

    The signature on 15 April rests on the record the five steps above leave behind.

    Every engagement
Most programs stop at 02. Examiners ask about 04 and 05.Running · 01 of 06
What you receive

The record you can hand over.

We map the report to Section 500.5 subsection by subsection, because that is how an examiner reads it. Every line carries a date.

What it requires, and what we do about it

The obligations testing can answer.

  1. Section 500.3, including (n) vulnerability management

    Written cybersecurity policies and procedures, approved at least annually by a senior officer or the governing body, with vulnerability management among the areas covered.

    We draft the vulnerability-management policy around the program, so it describes what actually runs and the testing produces its evidence.

    Program review
  2. Section 500.5, opening paragraph

    Written vulnerability-management policies and procedures, consistent with the risk assessment.

    The same policy, one level down: procedures that name the annual test, the continuous testing, the manual review and the remediation cadence.

    Program review
  3. Section 500.5(a)(1)

    Penetration testing from inside and outside the systems' boundaries, at least annually, by a qualified party.

    External and internal, by a CREST-accredited team that names its testers, every finding proven by exploitation.

    Penetration testing
  4. Section 500.5(a)(2)

    Automated scans, plus a manual review of the systems the scans do not cover, at a risk-assessed frequency and after any material change.

    Incenter runs the automated testing continuously. A senior reviews what the automation cannot reach. A material change triggers a re-run.

    Incenter
  5. Section 500.5(b)

    A monitoring process that keeps the entity promptly informed of new vulnerabilities.

    The continuous testing is that process, and its findings arrive with proof.

    Incenter
  6. Section 500.5(c)

    Timely remediation, prioritized by the risk each vulnerability poses.

    Ranked by what would breach you, closed in a sprint, re-tested to show the fix held.

    Closure sprint
  7. Section 500.17

    Notice of certain incidents within 72 hours, and an annual certification of material compliance by 15 April.

    The report and the re-test record are what the certification rests on.

    Every engagement
Questions we are asked

NYDFS Part 500, answered plainly.

Can one program cover Section 500.3, Section 500.5 and the certification?

Yes, if the policy is written around the program rather than beside it. We help draft the vulnerability-management policy and procedures, Incenter runs the automated scans and the monitoring, our seniors run the manual review and the annual test, the closure sprint handles risk-ranked remediation, and the evidence is mapped subsection by subsection for the 15 April certification. One system, with one record.

Does Incenter satisfy the annual penetration test in 500.5(a)(1)?

Incenter's continuous testing answers 500.5(a)(2) and (b) for the surface it covers. The annual test in (a)(1) is a scoped test from inside and outside the boundaries by a qualified party, which we deliver as its own engagement.

What does "qualified" mean?

The regulation does not define it. Examiners look at independence, method and credentials. OSec is CREST-accredited and every report names the people who did the testing.

How is "timely" remediation judged?

Against your risk ranking and your own policy. The record has to show the ranking, the dates and the re-test, so the judgment is visible.

We are a small covered entity. Does 500.5 apply to us?

Limited exemptions exist under Section 500.19, and most covered entities must meet 500.5 in full. Your counsel confirms your category.

Does the test report go to DFS?

No. It supports your annual certification and is available to examiners on request.